kate commonsense
@KateCommonsense
Excluding males from female CR doesn't imply males (regardless of presentation or identity)are all or predominantly predators ,it implies some are and we don't know which ones so we exclude them all for safeguarding reasons.Its not difficult.
NC - keeping TW out doesn't imply that TW are predators. JR - what rule is being considered now? NC - I'll try again. If you exclude TW from womens facilities, that exclusion doesn't imply all TW are predators. Logical structure. DU - I believe it implies large proportion are
That's a shame...
I will be limiting replies to my posts to verified users only moving forward. I am hoping this will reduce spam and troll replies. And, frankly, people should verify their accounts to help support X and free speech.
It's a shame Hannah limits replies because i wanted to ask if she is arguing that we shouldn't bother with societal rules/laws because some people will violate them ?
Excellent Q by @kirith_ae ‘how feasible is it for organisations to stop anyone using toilet facilities.’ The Baroness refuses to answer and defers to her Chief Exec. He waffles on about the EHRC focus being on ‘having gender neutral toilets’ But that’s not possible everywhere
I wonder why an elected parliamentarian would tweet this and limit replies ?
It makes complete sense that he was Slytherin.
Molecular geneticist explains how biological sex is unchangeable #peterb... youtube.com/shorts/w7RbFWY… via @YouTube
@madisonW92 replied to this tweet saying ...They aren't men and its like talking to a toddler,then limited replies. I wanted to say i didn't mention men.....
Women dont have a better chance of safety if males can access their same sex spaces in circumstances of vulnerability. Women get hurt if males can access their spaces. If some males feel unsafe in male spaces they should campaign for thier own spaces, not take female spaces.
Limited replies and hidden replies from those asking if males should have access to female changing rooms....
I was over the moon to see our UNISON women's conference overwhelmingly endorse a motion that supports our transgender and non-binary comrades 🏳️⚧️ We all want a truly inclusive union! I have consistently opposed all forms of discrimination I always will ✊
The truth is on trial #IStandWithSandiePeggie #thetruthisontrial
Is DU saying a woman who says she is uncomfortable with a male in the female changing room constitutes harassment of the male?!
DU Y but there are various other considerations. Not sure what it's got to do with height. NC you are middle class, privileged DU not aware of C social class, not sure relevance NC You expected her to bend to your will. DU, no, I wanted for her to stop harassing me.
Is Dr Upton saying you it isn't right that you need a large gamete and small gamete to produce a baby?
NC a number of w using that CR may hold the view that you need a large gamete and small gamete person to produce babies. DU I'm sure there are people who believe those things. Doesn't make them right or allowed to disrespect people who thing otherwise.
This farcical in a court of law. A male is not a female.
DU - so you are a man and you wish to be seen as a woman JR - there are lots of questions there, one at a time. NC - you are a TW, not a Cis woman DU - yes NC - don't have a female body DU - that has no definition, I'm female and I have a body so biologically female
Dr Upton has already said he disagrees he is male.
DU - I was told I could. I can't speak of her feelings, I have to get changed and so I did. I'm sure we wil talk about Dr Searle I told her what was going on and just like everyone else I continued using the facilities NC - you describe yourself as TW, so born male, male body
Dr Upton disagrees he is male . Ask him why?
DU - to match gender identity? NC - is the diff that you speak in a softer higher voice htan other men? DU - again I'm not a man, but there are women with low voices, and men with high ones, some people use it for gender expression NC - so what is it that makes you a woman?
Thing is, women don't know "his intention" thats what makes him a safeguarding risk.
DU - third scenario? NC - no a continuation, he closes the door. Do you agree, it's positively menacing? DU - define menacing NC - ordinary meaning DU - could be but I couldn't speak to his intention.
This really seems the crux of the matter. A male says he is not male in a court of law and that anyone who disagrees or doesn't want him in the female CR is transphobic and bigoted ...
offence against their privacy. DU I disagree that I'm male. Y'll have to ask them how they experienced me. NC Re interactions w KS, It ws reasonable for u to get mgmt back up if problems DU We agreed I cld use the CR, and expectation of it being discussed
What do we do when a male says "i disagree that i am male" in court of law?
offence against their privacy. DU I disagree that I'm male. Y'll have to ask them how they experienced me. NC Re interactions w KS, It ws reasonable for u to get mgmt back up if problems DU We agreed I cld use the CR, and expectation of it being discussed
Not only didnt he answer ,he blocked me foe asking... Which speaks volumes.
I bet he doesn't answer.
This seems to have got me blocked by @terrychristian ..
Males cant be female even if they "want to be".... Women are female never ever male. Sex is immutable. Why do you think males can be females if they "want to be"?
Women can see a male gynaecologist or request a female gynaecologist as best meets their care needs. It isn't transphobic. Also an intimate examination by a male gynaecologist would require a female chaperone to protect the pt and the Dr.