Cath πππ
@rugbycath
Rugby, golf & politics. Edinburgh Rugby season ticket holder & Scottish Rugby fan. Adult Human Female. #TeamCarrotCottage π°
In a nutshell...
Of course Dr. Kate Searle, A&E Consultant with NHS Fife, knows what sex she is. She also knows what sex you are, else she couldn't do her job. And she knows what sex Dr. Upton is, too. This ideology makes utter liars of doctors, the very people we must trust the most.
HR let Dr Upton edit the notes of his interview - notes that were produced from the recording of the interview (the recording is destroyed)π±π±π± They had a Teams meeting to edit the original notes of his interview (no minutes were taken) #SandiePeggie
NC to KS: the βusual rules donβt apply when dealing with Dr Upton, do they?β An email from KS to Dr Upton passed on support from Jamie Doyle, head of nursing. βShouldnβt it have been obviousβ¦ that was a wholly improper message...β KS: βIn hindsight, yes.β telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/07/2β¦
Thereβs nothing quite as repulsive as watching a crowd of people humiliating, jeering & abusing a person in this manner. You might not agree with what he says, but to become part of a pack of braying bullies is repugnantβ¦ sickening mob mentalityβ¦
Of course Dr. Kate Searle, A&E Consultant with NHS Fife, knows what sex she is. She also knows what sex you are, else she couldn't do her job. And she knows what sex Dr. Upton is, too. This ideology makes utter liars of doctors, the very people we must trust the most.
Upton is in fact legally a man So what are the consequences for a KC who repeatedly contradicts a legal fact during a legal proceeding that hinges on that fact?
Jane Russell repeatedly insists that Dr Upton is not a man.
My takeaway from todayβs clown show is that after the Christmas Eve incident, Theo & Kate wanted to get a patient safety incident against Sandie to make the case more compelling. They identified an HCA who allegedly witnessed an incident between Upton & Sandie. Her statementβ¦
After all theyβve endured as a family, to see this lovely photo of Sandie and her mum smiling in the Herald is so uplifting.
If this shocked you, please follow the hearing. @tribunaltweets is reporting it live. Sex-based rights are on trial. The Sandie Peggie case isnβt fringe. Itβs the futureβunless we make it stop. #SexMatters #PeggieTribunal #EqualityAct #SingleSexSpaces
Sandie Peggie's daughter leads fightback after claims her mum is 'homophobic' scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-β¦
Pretty shocking evidence today at the tribunal everyone is watching - Key witness in Sandie Peggie tribunal with NHS Fife admits 'confidentiality ruin' heraldscotland.com/news/25336963.β¦
Sandie Peggie was right to raise concerns about sharing a female changing room with a biological male Now, two more nurses haveΒ reported the βextremely hostile atmosphereβ they experienced for defending single-sex spaces This SNP-driven ideology must end heraldscotland.com/politics/viewpβ¦
The Sandie Peggie tribunal is very damaging not just to @nhsfife but to @NHSNSS as a whole. After all who would trust an organisation where a consultant says she knows she's female because it's on her birth certificate but personally isn't an expert on recognising a baby's sex?
βthe charge against Peggie was built backwards. A conclusion first, then a motive, then a narrative, then finally some retrofitted evidence. The log never existed. The hate incident report was embellished β Perfectly put ππ»ππ»ππ»
Some of our members attended the tribunal in Dundee today to give support to Sandie Peggie and her family. We were shocked to hear some of the completely unscientific comments made by supposed intelligent healthcare professionals which to be quite honest would make most womenβ¦
An excellent point!
Dr Searle claims she knows she's female because it says so on her birth certificate yet Dr Uptonβs birth certificate says male. π€
The brilliant @Darcy_Graham is everything a British and Irish Lion should be. In 15 minutes he showed the world exactly what us fans of @EdinburghRugby have known all along. Iβm heartbroken for him but so proud of him. Speedy recovery Darcy. #ALionForever π¦ππ§‘
I cannot even begin to express how angry I am, that this toxic idealogy has not only been allowed but encouraged in all our public institutions to the detriment of the entire population.
Day 6 | PM Session | Peggie v NHS Fife & Dr Upton π§¨Weaponising Narrative: From Fabricated Logs to Hate Reports It began with an email. On 29 December 2023, just hours after a fraught exchange in the womenβs changing room, Dr. Kate Searle sent a message to every consultant inβ¦
The lad from Hawick that became a Lion π¦ Proud of you Darcy! π°
Our ruling is not contentious or a hypothesis. It's straightforward. According to the Equality Act, as NC says, Upton is legally and biologically a man. It isn't for Jane Russell to relitigate this at a tribunal.
NC - man. He's insisted he's entitled to be there, focus on that. JR - unfair premise, DU is not a man, a she's a TW NC - .. J - there was an objection NC - DU is a TW and so DU is a man. Legally speaking in FWS EQA he's a man JR - FWS not agreed J - we need to hear submissions